ERC3643 vs ERC1400: : Which Protocol for Secure Token Offerings?

Finding effective and sustainable energy storage technology is more important than ever in the quickly changing world of today. The need for strong energy storage systems grows as the use of renewable energy sources continues to grow. Two titans—ER1400 and ERC3643—have emerged in this continuing competition as key competitors in the battle to fundamentally alter the energy storage industry. With regard to grid stability, energy security, and carbon footprint reduction, these cutting-edge technologies have the potential to solve some of the most serious issues the energy sector is now facing.

In this article, we explore the unique characteristics, benefits, and uses of ERC3643 and ER1400 and provide a thorough comparison to highlight their distinctive benefits and drawbacks. Understanding the subtleties and capacities of these competing energy storage technologies is essential for helping the world move towards a cleaner and more sustainable future and for making choices that will help the environment now. In this article, we'll delve into the fascinating world of ERC3643 and ER1400 and uncover the conflict that might have a major impact on the future of the energy industry.

Introduction To Token Standards  

Token standards are a collection of preset guidelines and procedures that control how digital tokens operate and behave on a blockchain network. Tokens are digital assets that might include cryptocurrencies, utility tokens, security tokens, and non-fungible tokens (NFTs) in the context of blockchain technology. These guidelines are essential for guaranteeing consistency, compatibility, and security across various tokenized projects and decentralized applications (dApps) inside the blockchain ecosystem.

Blockchain-based economies are built on tokens, which make it possible to represent and transfer value, ownership, or access rights on a distributed ledger. Without token standards, any project may use its own particular token mechanisms, leading to a disjointed and ineffective environment.

What are ERC-3643 Tokens? 

The ERC-3643 security token standard establishes a set of guidelines for using ERC-20 tokens to represent a portion of real-world assets. By specifying a list of attributes that must be included in the token's contract, such as the asset's name, the quantity of tokens required to represent one unit of the asset, and the custodian's contract address, it does this. A collection of methods for interacting with tokenized assets are also defined by ERC-3643. These include transferring ownership of a token, exchanging a token for its underlying asset, and obtaining information about the asset.

To remedy some of the drawbacks of earlier token standards, such ERC-20, ERC-3643 was developed. Because there is no mechanism to trace the ownership of individual tokens, ERC-20 tokens are not suitable for expressing fractional ownership of physical assets. This restriction is addressed by ERC-3643, which mandates that token contracts maintain a record of who owns which tokens. As opposed to needing to transfer the complete token, this enables the transfer of ownership of a portion of a token.

Although ERC-3643 is still in development, it has the potential to be a significant advancement in the creation of tokenized assets.

Features of ERC-3643 

ERC3643 is ideal for regulated exchanges due to a number of characteristics. Among these characteristics are:

Permissioned tokens: ERC3643 tokens cannot be transferred to anybody; each transfer requires verification of the sender's and receiver's eligibility and identity. This is accomplished by looking up each user's ONCHAIN ID, a digital identity that includes attestations that have been signed by reputable claim issuers. Even on permission less blockchains, the ONCHAIN ID system makes sure that only users who comply with the established requirements may become token holders.

Compliance regulations: At the level of the smart contract, ERC3643 tokens may implement compliance regulations like as KYC/AML, investor accreditation, nation-specific limitations, holding periods, or transfer limits. The issuer or the regulator may specify these regulations, and they may be changed at any moment. An automated validator system that serves as a gatekeeper for each transfer verifies the compliance standards.

Token lifecycle management: Token lifecycle events supported by ERC3643 tokens include issuance, redemption, burning, minting, stopping, and freezing. The responsibilities given to the issuer and agent by the issuer to handle the token may both initiate these occurrences. Additionally, the issuer may assign some duties to other parties, including brokers, custodians, and markets.

Interoperability: ERC3643 tokens are EVM-compatible and can communicate with other Ethereum-based smart contracts. Additionally, they adhere to the ERC-20 protocol for fundamental token operations like balanceOf and transfer. Additionally, ERC3643 tokens may be exchanged and transferred between one ERC3643 token and another.

ERC3643 is an open-source protocol that anybody may use without charge. It is also audited. To assure its security and dependability, it has undergone an examination by Hacken, a reputable cybersecurity company. The Ethereum community has also studied it and approved it as a formal specification for permissioned tokens.

The ERC3643 security token standard for regulated exchanges provides a complete answer for tokenizing physical assets in a legal and effective manner. In order to provide trust, compliance, and control on a shared infrastructure, it makes use of the capabilities of blockchain technology and decentralized identification. Additionally, it improves the transferability and liquidity of tokens for both token holders and issuers.

Use Cases of ERC-3643 

Numerous use cases in various sectors have used RC3643, showcasing its adaptability and interoperability. These are a few of the usage cases:

Securities: Any financial asset, including funds, stocks, bonds, ETFs, and loans, may be tokenized using ERC3643. Securities may be tokenized to save costs, boost liquidity, and broaden the investor base. For instance, Inveniam Capital Partners tokenized $260 million worth of commercial real estate in the US using ERC3643, giving investors access to fractional ownership and enabling them can sell the assets on secondary markets.

- Physical commodities or rare objects, like vehicles, wine, or watches, may be tokenized using ERC3643. Commodities may be tokenized to increase efficiency, establish new markets, and improve provenance. For instance, Rooba.Finance tokenized crude oil barrels using ERC3643 to let traders to transact oil futures contracts on the blockchain.

- E-Money: ERC3643 may be used to tokenize fiat money or stablecoins, generating instantaneous, programmatically transferable digital currency. E-money tokenization may make remittances, payments, and settlements easier. For instance, Bitstamp issued EURt, a stablecoin backed by euros that complies entirely with the rules of the European Central Bank, using ERC3643.

- Loyalty Programs: By tokenizing loyalty points or prizes, ERC3643 enables the creation of digital tokens that may be redeemed or traded for products and services. The retention, engagement, and pleasure of customers may all be raised by tokenizing loyalty programs. In order to develop Melon Points, a loyalty token that compensates consumers for utilizing Avantgarde Finance's asset management platform, the company utilized ERC3643.

- Music: ERC3643 may be used to tokenize music rights or royalties, generating digital bonds that serve as a representation of the artists' potential future revenue streams. Tokenizing music may support artists, boost revenue, and promote creativity. For instance, Nusic created Non fungible tokens bonds using ERC3643, a brand-new non-fungible token type that enables artists to sell their music directly to customers and investors.

A complete solution for several markets and applications, ERC3643 is a security token standard for the tokenization of real-world assets. In order to provide trust, compliance, and control over a shared infrastructure, it makes use of the capabilities of blockchain technology and decentralized identification. It also offers token holders and issuers improved transferability and liquidity.

Pros and Cons of ERC-3643  

Pros of ERC-3643

Compliance: ERC3643 makes sure that only authorized users are able to store and transfer tokens by comparing their on-chain identities and credentials to preset regulations. This lowers the possibility of breaking the law and improves investment safety.

Interoperability: ERC3643 is ERC-20 compliant, allowing it to take use of Ethereum's current ecosystem and infrastructure. Decentralized exchanges or lending platforms, for example, may interact with ERC3643 tokens as well as other protocols and programs that allow permissioned tokens.

Flexibility: ERC3643 enables token issuers to modify the rules and features of their tokens to suit their own requirements and preferences. For instance, issuers might specify the requirements for creating, redeeming, stopping, freezing, or burning tokens. In order to adjust to evolving conditions or legislation, they might also alter the rules over time.

Open Source: ERC3643 is a free and open-source protocol that anybody may use. Additionally, it is administered by a group of founding members who support its upkeep and growth. The procedure is reviewed by an established security company and is developed in accordance with best standards.

Cons of ERC3643

Complexity: The ERC3643 protocol entails a number of actors and components, including identity registries, compliance validators, trusted issuers, claim themes, etc. The tokenization process becomes more complicated and time-consuming as a result, and several parties must coordinate and work together.

Scalability: The functioning and security of ERC3643 rely on the Ethereum network. The performance and cost of ERC3643 transactions may be impacted by Ethereum's low throughput and high fees. In addition, Ethereum is in the process of switching from proof-of-work to proof-of-stake, which might cause volatility and uncertainty in the near future.

Privacy: In order to access permissioned tokens, users must publish their names and login information on the blockchain according to ERC3643. Some users who wish to use pseudonyms or stay anonymous may be concerned about their privacy as a result. Although ERC3643 enables zero-knowledge proofs to safeguard user privacy, this technology is currently in its experimental stage and is not yet commonly used.

Scale your Blockchain projects with us

What are the ERC-1400 Token Standards?  

A standard known as ERC1400 combines new and current ERC standards to solve the unique requirements and difficulties of security tokens. The most popular token standard on Ethereum, ERC-20, is built upon for its foundational functionality, but it also supports the following extra features and interfaces:

Transfer restrictions: The ERC1400 standard enables issuers to establish and enforce limitations on who may possess and transfer tokens based on the individuals' identities and credentials on the blockchain. Compliance with KYC/AML, accreditation, or jurisdictional standards is ensured in this way.

Transfer information: ERC1400 enables operators and issuers to add metadata to token transfers, such as transfer justifications, document references, or investor information. By doing this, token transactions become more transparent and auditable.

Document management: ERC1400 enables issuers to store and modify token-related documents like prospectuses, terms and conditions, or legal opinions. As a result, regulators and investors may do their due diligence and disclose information more easily.

Forced Transfer: Forced transfers are possible under ERC1400 in the event of legal action, money recovery, or corporate activities. Issuers or authorized agents may carry out these transfers. Because of this, issuers are able to abide with legal requirements, tax laws, or shareholder rights.

Partial fungibility: ERC1400 enables issuers to divide each holder's balance into sub-balances with certain characteristics or limitations. As a result, investors' understanding of their ownership rights and duties is improved.

Features of ERC-1400   

In order to solve some of the drawbacks of ERC-20, the ERC-1400 token standard for Ethereum was developed. It has characteristics like:

Gas refunding in line with EIP-1559: This makes sure that consumers are reimbursed for any wasted gas when they submit a transaction.

Integration of the Chainlink VRF: This enables the use of provably fair randomization in smart contracts.

Support for multiple signatures: This enables the approval of transactions by several parties prior to execution.

Transfers and approvals from smart contracts: This enables smart contracts to send and receive tokens on behalf of users.

Despite being in its early stages of development, ERC-1400 has the potential to be a more robust and adaptable token standard than ERC-20.

Use Cases of ERC-1400 

Many different asset classes and marketplaces may be tokenized using ERC1400, including:

Publicly traded equities and bonds: With ERC1400, public company shares or bonds may be issued and exchanged on the blockchain at cheaper costs, with quicker settlement, and with more liquidity. With the aid of forced transfers or partitioned balances, ERC1400 may also enable corporate activities like dividends, votes, or splits.

Private placements: Using ERC1400, private corporations or funds may issue and trade stock or debt on the blockchain with better access, transparency, and compliance. ERC1400 may assist with investor rights including redemption, conversion, and exit by leveraging transfer information or document management.

Real estate: Using ERC1400, fractional ownership in real estate assets or money may be issued and traded on the blockchain with fewer restrictions, more efficiency, and a wider reach. By using document management or partitioned balances, ERC1400 may also assist property management tasks like rent collecting, upkeep, or appraisal.

Commodities: The ERC1400 standard may be used to create and exchange tokens backed by real-world goods like gold, oil, or metals on the blockchain with less middlemen, more security, and immediate delivery. By implementing forced transfers or document management, ERC1400 may also facilitate commonplace storage, verification, or transfer.

E-money: The ERC1400 standard enables the creation and exchange of tokens backed by fiat money or stablecoins on the blockchain, with quicker transactions, reduced transaction costs, and more programmability. With the aid of transfer information or compliance checks, ERC1400 may also assist payment systems, remittance services, or international transfers.

Loyalty programs: ERC1400 may be used with more control, flexibility, and interoperability to create and manage tokens that reflect incentives or loyalty points from brands or businesses on the blockchain. ERC1400 may assist loyalty program tactics such as the establishment, redemption, or transfer of points or incentives by using transfer information or partitioned balances.

Comparison: ERC3643 VS ERC1400

The Ethereum blockchain uses the ERC-3643 and ERC-1400 token specifications. To address some of the drawbacks of ERC-1400, a more recent standard called ERC-3643 was developed. The following are a few of the main distinctions between the two standards:

  • In contrast to ERC-1400, which only accepts fungible tokens, ERC-3643 enables a variety of asset kinds.
  • The more effective storage mechanism in ERC-3643 may lower gas prices.
  • ERC-3643 is easy to extend, making it simpler to add new functionality.

ERC-3643 is an all-around more advanced and adaptable token standard than ERC-1400. However, because of its greater maturity and bigger development community, ERC-1400 is still used extensively.

Let's build together on Blockchain

Conclusion

In the realm of banking and digital assets, security tokens have a rich history. Security tokens were a potential concept as blockchain technology grew in popularity. A security token reflects ownership in a regulated asset and gives investors a stake in things like stocks, commodities, or real estate. Security tokens, unlike conventional financial instruments, make use of blockchain's transparency, immutability, and decentralization to speed up transactions, reduce fraud, and increase liquidity. By using smart contract, security token functionality may be effectively designed to follow applicable laws and automate procedures, guaranteeing that all participants abide by the tokenized asset's stated terms. A diversified and dynamic ecosystem has been created within the larger blockchain and cryptocurrency environment as a result of the creation of security tokens, which has given rise to multiple token types that each cater to distinct asset classes, risk profiles, and investor preferences.

The security token industry has seen impressive development in recent years as more companies and investors become aware of the potential advantages of this unique financial tool. A high level of compliance has been maintained while security tokens have transcended national borders and regulatory hurdles to provide investors with unmatched access to global investment possibilities. Security tokens make ensuring that dividends, dividends, and other entitlements are distributed and settled in an efficient manner via the use of smart contracts. In addition, the smooth transfer of security tokens has been made possible by the interoperability across different blockchain networks, significantly boosting their liquidity and tradability. Security tokens are changing the financial landscape, opening doors to new investment opportunities, and transforming existing financial processes for a more inclusive and safe future. This is becoming more and more obvious as the security token market continues to develop and evolve.

On the Ethereum blockchain, security tokens may be issued and managed using the two extensive and adaptable token specifications known as ERC3643 and ERC1400. To enhance token transaction compliance, transparency, and auditability, they provide a number of features and interfaces. They work with the ERC-20 and ERC-777 standards and take use of the Ethereum ecosystem and infrastructure already in place. Everyone is welcome to use and contribute to the community-driven, open-source protocols ERC3643 and ERC1400.

Next Article

Tokenized Securities - Transforming Financial Markets with Blockchain

Research

NFTs, or non-fungible tokens, became a popular topic in 2021's digital world, comprising digital music, trading cards, digital art, and photographs of animals. Know More

Blockchain is a network of decentralized nodes that holds data. It is an excellent approach for protecting sensitive data within the system. Know More

Workshop

The Rapid Strategy Workshop will also provide you with a clear roadmap for the execution of your project/product and insight into the ideal team needed to execute it. Learn more

It helps all the stakeholders of a product like a client, designer, developer, and product manager all get on the same page and avoid any information loss during communication and on-going development. Learn more

Why us

We provide transparency from day 0 at each and every step of the development cycle and it sets us apart from other development agencies. You can think of us as the extended team and partner to solve complex business problems using technology. Know more

Other Related Services From Rejolut

Chainlink Vs Polkadot

The Dogfight Between The Altcoins Is Getting Interesting Every Day.

Blockchain in Financial Services

Blockchain technology is one of the most promising financial industries.

Blockchain in Insurance Industry

Insurance policies have always been difficult to manage and record.

Why Rejolut?

1 Reduce Cost

We’ll work with you to develop a true ‘MVP’ (Minimum Viable Product). We will “cut the fat” and design a lean product that has only the critical features.

2 Define Product Strategy

Designing a successful product is a science and we help implement the same Product Design frameworks used by the most successful products in the world (Ethereum, Solana, Hedera etc.)

3 Speed

In an industry where being first to market is critical, speed is essential. Rejolut's rapid prototyping framework(RPF) is the fastest, most effective way to take an idea to development. It is choreographed to ensure we gather an in-depth understanding of your idea in the shortest time possible.

4 Limit Your Risk

Rejolut RPF's helps you identify problem areas in your concept and business model. We will identify your weaknesses so you can make an informed business decision about the best path for your product.

Our Clients

We as a blockchain development company take your success personally as we strongly believe in a philosophy that "Your success is our success and as you grow, we grow." We go the extra mile to deliver you the best product.

BlockApps

CoinDCX

Tata Communications

Malaysian airline

Hedera HashGraph

Houm

Xeniapp

Jazeera airline

EarthId

Hbar Price

EarthTile

MentorBox

TaskBar

Siki

The Purpose Company

Hashing Systems

TraxSmart

DispalyRide

Infilect

Verified Network

What Our Clients Say

Don't just take our words for it

I have worked with developers from many countries for over 20 years on some of the most high traffic websites and apps in the world. The team at rejolut.com are some of most professional, hard working and intelligent developers I have ever worked with rejolut.com have worked tirelessly and gone beyond the call of duty in order to have our dapps ready for Hedera Hashgraph open access. They are truly exceptional and I can’t recommend them enough.
Joel Bruce
Co-founder, hbarprice.com and earthtile.io
Rejolut is staying at the forefront of technology. From participating in, and winning, hackathons to showcase their ability to implement almost any piece of code. To contributing in open source software for anyone in the world to benefit from the increased functionality. They’ve shown they can do it all.
Pablo Peillard
Founder, Hashing Systems
Enjoyed working with the Rejolut team. Professional and with a sound understanding of smart contracts and blockchain. Easy to work with and I highly recommend the team for future projects. Kudos!
Zhang
Founder, 200eth
They have great problem-solving skills. The best part is they very well understand the business fundamentals and at the same time are apt with domain knowledge.
Suyash Katyayani
CTO, Purplle

Think Big, Act Now & Scale Fast

Speed up your Generative AI & Blockchain Projects with our proven frame work

We are located at

We are located at

 

We have developed around 50+ blockchain projects and helped companies to raise funds.
You can connect directly to our Polkadot developers using any of the above links.

Talk  to Blockchain Developer